Joint Pain Forum – News you can use!
Best way to see damage in knee osteoarthritis
June 17, 2007
Taking x-rays of the semi-flexed knee is the most accurate way of
evaluating structural damage in patients with knee osteoarthritis (OA)
according to results presented today at EULAR 2007, the Annual European
Congress of Rheumatology in Barcelona, Spain.
In knee OA, there are several radiographic views from which structural
damage can be identified and several tools from which damage to the
knee can be assessed. Radiographic measurements and associated data
were gathered from 1,759 radiographs of fully extended (EV) and
semi-flexed (SF) knees and analysed using semi-quantitative scores: the
Kellgren Lawrence (KL) scale, and the Osteoarthritis Research Society
International (OARSI) joint space width (JSW) scale. They were also
assessed using precise measurement of JSW in millimeters.
Results of this study, undertaken as part of collaboration between the
Outcome Measures in Rheumatology initiative and the Osteoarthritis
Research Society International (OMERACT-OARSI), were analysed with the
aim of comparing different radiographic views and stratifying
techniques for accuracy in indicating progress of structural damage in
knee OA.
The highest inter-rater reliability (see note to Editors) was found in
the precise measurement of JSW in extended knees (kappa 0.86
(0.76-0.96) compared to kappa 0.56 (0.38-0.73) in using the Kellgren
Lawrence scale and 0.48 (0.32-0.64) for using the OARSI scale).
Intra-rater reliability was also high for categorical JSW in extended
and semi-flexed views, which means these measures are highly
reproducible across readings and across readers. Sensitivity to change
was highest for categorical JSW in the semi-flexed knee with a
standardized response mean of 0.49, compared to 0.22 and 0.34
respectively for semi-flexed knee views. This means measurement of JSW
is more able to detect change over time or after treatment than the
other techniques.
Study author Dr Laure Gossec, of Cochin Hospital,
Paris, commented, "Measuring joint space width, in particular in the
semi-flexed knee, has been shown to be the most reliable and responsive
way to determine structural severity in knee OA trials as overall,
reliability and responsiveness were higher for JSW (in particular on
semi-flexed view) than for the other scoring techniques.".
Inter-observer reliability was assessed in 50 sample
x-rays with the aim of assessing the degree of comparability between 2
physicians assessing the x-rays. Sensitivity to change was assessed in
50 sample x-rays with the aim of determining change over time of the
diagnosed findings.
Construct validity (see note to Editors) was assessed
through logistic regression and adjusted on age, race, sex and body
mass index. -European League Against Rheumatism
MEMBERS
AREA
| Site
Map | CONTACT
US
Privacy
| Terms
| 
